Adaptive secure data transmission method for OSI level 1
5.9.5. Sensitivity of the Soft DFT Detection in Granular Noisy
Simulation settings in Figure 5.23 are:
- Granular noise is generated in the ADM-channel and it is present in the detected signal.
- AWGN noise is added to the signal in the granular channel before D/A conversion in the
- Analog waveform and the symbol value detection method is soft detection using a 26-point
Fig. 5.23 Performance of DFT soft detection in AWGN noise ADM-channel
The evaluated granular channel was found to be not very suitable for analog data transmission.
Figure 5.23 presents the amplitude variations of a three-tone component in respect to granularity
and AWGN noise level. The granularity is the main source of variations. The signal amplitude
values vary form normal to about -20 %. The increasing AWGN noise increases the amplitude
variations slowly to about -40%.
5.9.6. Sensitivity of the Soft DFT Detection in Multi-Path Noisy
General simulation settings in Figure 5.24 are as before and:
- Granular noise is not present.
- AWGN noise is set on the noise levels S/N= 28…77 dB dB.
- Single-tone transmission (ASCII, QAM) is used as the signal.
- The reference received normal value used in the simulation is without granular or additive
noise (at noise floor S/N>>80 dB) and without multi-path propagation.
- Multipath signals (I) are generated with additive signal components.
Fig. 5.24 Performance of DFT soft detection in multi-path noise channel
Figure 5.24 presents the received signal amplitude versus the S/I in the multi-path signal case.
The multi-path components are made according to random phase and an exponential amplitude
distribution. In the figure the mean power of all interfering multi-path components are calculated
and the resulting S/I is used as a variable. In general, the first multi-path component is the
main component of interfering signal power I of the S/I ratio. The reference signal is on the
normal amplitude level, amplitude=1.
The multi-path error performance of the soft detection system is seen as the deviation of the
amplitude compared to the normal amplitude value (ampl = 1). In the simulated results the
multi-path signal varies with the received interference signal level. Error increases to 25% with
the decreasing S/I levels 15…7 dB. The deviation in the variation is higher at lower S/N levels
as expected. High S/N-values (76…77 dB) represent pure multi-path effects.
5.9.7. Orthogonal Signal Space
Simulation settings in Figure 5.25 are:
- Granular noise is not present.
- AWGN noise is on the noise floor level S/N>>80 dB.
- The single-tone, two-tone and three-tone signals are generated as before in an IDFTprocess,
A=0.5 and random phase.
- Detection is made using 26-point DFT optimized to each frequency used in the multi-carrier
Fig. 5.25 Performance of DFT soft detection method
Figure 5.25 presents the performance of DFT in multi-carrier signal detection. Five different
signal spaces are evaluated one-tone, two-tone and three-tone spaces. Each signal is detected
with its normal amplitude value. No distortion components are found. The system is orthogonal
and the detection method is matched to the signal frequency.
Errors in the soft detection are due to noise channel, granular noise generated in voice coding
and parameter errors (frequency) in transmission. These situations have been discussed earlier
and presented in Figures 5.19-5.24.
A new adaptive method for data transmission over different radio or telecommunication channels
has been developed. The results are based on the modeling and simulation system, described
in chapters 4-5, and the use of DFT (discrete Fourier transmission) in the soft generation
and detection of waveforms. It is a band-limited variant of a generally known OFDM technology.
The basic element is the adaptive modem, which has a standard electronic interface to supported
communication systems and software algorithms for selecting its own functionality (synchronization,
waveform, modulation etc). The basic theory used was made by Shannon, Fourier
The complex waveforms generated in the simulations and in a prototype modem are the practical
solutions for the capacity limit of Shannon’s theory. The selection of adaptive waveforms
have been simulated and tested in the field in 2000, which ended the investigation of the method
by proving its functionality in practice.
The main result and benefit of this work is a theory and an early version (prototype modems) of
the adaptive band-limited multi-carrier data communication system for alert communications,
telemedicine purposes and other security communication needs on the physical level. The including
of a warning multi-tone into a broadcasted waveform is proof of the effectiveness of a
steganographic method used in the signal space.
Data communication is improved with the presented adaptive waveforms and the secure adaptive
communication (modulation) method compared to known band-limited methods as
- We have the physical OSI level security in local networks.
- We have secure band-limited end-to-end voice channels.
- We can optimize the bandwidth versus bit rate at the selected quality level (S/N).
- We can manage bit error rates in communication with adaptive selection of waveforms
These results are simulated and tested in the field proving that the goals of the thesis have been
achieved in general with the presented adaptive data communication method.
List of Original Papers
This thesis is based on the following publications of the author.
1. [Lal97a] Lallo, P., Analysis and Measurements of Information Transmission over an
Adaptive Delta Modulated Voice Channel, IEEE Military Communications Conference
November 2-5, 1997, in Proceedings of MILCOM 97, Monterey, CA 1997, pp.
2. [Lal97b] Lallo, P., Investigation of Data Transmission over an Adaptive Delta
Modulated Voice Channel by Simulations using a Spreadsheet Program, IEEE Military
Communications Conference November 2-5, 1997, in Proceedings of MILCOM
97, Monterey, CA 1997, pp. 554-559.
3. [Lal99] Lallo, P., Signal Classification by Discrete Fourier Transform, in Proceedings
of Milcom 1999, Atlantic City, NJ, IEEE ComSoc Digital Library, USA, 1999,
4. [Lal00] Lallo, P., Adaptive Modem, EuroComm2000, München, Germany.
5. [Lal01] Lallo, P., Adaptive Software Modem Technology, Proceedings of Milcom
2001, McLean, VA, IEEE ComSoc Digital Library, USA, 2001, pp. 175-179.
6. [Lal02] Lallo, P., Basic Theory of Adaptive Data Transmission,in Proceedings of
MILCOM 2002, Anaheim, CA, IEEE ComSoc Digital Library, USA, 2002, pp.
7. [Lal04a] Lallo, P., Modeling and Simulations of Biomedical Data Networks,
ESM2004 SCS Europe, Magdeburg, Germany, 2004.
8. [Lal04b] Lallo, P., Robust Simulation of Waveforms, Proceedings of Milcom 2004
CD, Monterey, CA, USA, 2004.
9. [Lal75] Lallo, P., Analysis of a Special Telecommunication Network and Associated
Factors, Licentiate Thesis, Helsinki University of Technology, 1975, 88 pages.
10. [Lal87] Lallo, P., The Evaluation of the Availability of the Telecommunication
Networks, Report3/87, ISBN 951-754-158-9, ISSN 0781-7622, Helsinki University
of Technology 19.5.1987, 75 pages.
[Agu03] Aguiar, A., Gross J., Wireless Channel Models, Technical University Berlin,
Telecommunication Networks Group, TKN Technical Report TKN-03-007, Berlin,
[Alc92] Alcatel, Electrical Communication, Defence Communications, Volume 65 No
3, pp. 233-256, 1992.
[Big91] Biglieri, E., et. al., Introduction to Trellis-Coded Modulation with Applications,
New York, Macmillan, 1991.
[Bos17] Bose, A. C., Fourier series and its influence on some of the developments of
mathematical analysis, Bulletin of the Calcutta Mathematical Society 9 (1917-8), 71-84.
[Bro93] Brown, D.W., Fargues, M.P., SPC Toolbox An Interactive Matlab Package for
Signal Modeling and Analysis and Communications (with Speech Analysis and Linear
Systems Modeling), Technical Report no. NPSEC-93943-5121, Naval Post-graduate
School, Monterey, 1993.
[Bur94] Burrus, C. S., et. al., Computer-Based Exercises for Signal Processing Using
MATLAB• , Prentice-Hall International, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1994.
[Bus02] Bushko, R. G., Future of Health Technology, IOS Press, Amsterdam, The
[Cac93] CACI Products Company, Comnet III User’s Manual, Version 1.0, La Jolla,
[Car86] Carlson, A. B., Communication Systems An Introduction to Signals and Noise
in Electrical Communication, Third Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York,
[Cha66] Chang, R.W., High Speed Multichannel Data Transmission with Bandlimited
Orthogonal Signals, Bell System Technology Journal, Vol. 45, pp. 1745-1796, 1966.
[Com90] Comdisco Systems, Inc., Signal Processing Worksystem, January 31, 1990.
[Com92] Comparetto, G. .M., A Technical Description of the Brilliant Pebbles Communications
Simulator (BPCOMMSIM) Capability at the National Test Facility (NTF),
Colorado Springs, The MITRE Corporation, 1992.
[Coo65] Cooley, J. W., Tukey, J. W., An algorithm for the machine calculation of complex
Fourier series, Mathematics of Computation, 19, 90, pp. 297-301, 1965.
[deJ52] DeJager, F., Delta Modulation, A Method of P.C.M. Transmission Using the
One-Unit Code, Philips Res. Rep., Vol. 7, No 6, pp. 442-466, 1952.
[Del46] Deloraine, E. M., van Miero, S., Derjavitch, B., Methode et système de transmission
par impulsions, French Patent 932140, Aug. 1946.
[Ead01] Eades, P., Eds, J. J., Visual Information Processing, Australian Computer Society,
Inc, 2001. Copyright © 2001, Australian Computer Society, Inc. This paper appeared
at Visualisation 2000, Pan-Sydney Workshop on Visual Information Processing.
Conferences in Research and Practice in Information Technology, Vol. 2. P. Eades and
J.Jin, Eds. Reproduction for academic, not-for profit purposes permitted provided this
text is included, 2001.
[Eng03] Engels, M., Wireless OFDM Systems - How to make them work? IMEC, Belgium,
Kluwer Academic Publishers, ISBN 1-4020-7116-7, 2003.
[Eur86] EUROCOM D/1, Document, Unclassified 1977-1986.
[Fdf03] Finnish Defence Forces, Telecommunication Laboratory / Centre for Wireless
Communications, University of Oulu, Finnish Software Radio Programme, ISBN:951-
[Gal68] Gallager, R. G., Information Theory and Reliable Communication, John Wiley
and Sons, Inc, New York. 1968.
[Gal01] Gallager, R. G., Claude E. Shannon: A Retrospective on His Life, Work, and
Impact, IEEE Transactions on Information Theory, pp. 2681-2695, November 2001.
[Gol70] Goldberg R. R., Fourier Transforms, The Syndics of the Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1970.
[Guo02] Guo, Y., Cavallaro, J. R., Post-compensation of rf non-linearity in mobile ofdm
systems by estimation of memory-less polynomial, Dept. of Electrical and Computer
Engineering - Rice University, 2002.
[Har82] Harris, F. J., The Discrete Fourier Transform Applied to Time Domain Signal
Processing, pp. 13-22, IEEE Communications Magazine, Vol. 20, No. 3, May 1982.
[Har05] Harrington, D., Romascanu, D., IETF Bridge WG Transition to IEEE 802.1
[Hip03] Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), Health Insurance Portability
and Accountability Act (HIPAA), USA, February 20. 2003.
[Ima91] Proceedings of The Second International Conference of Image Management
and Communication in Patient Care: New Technologies for Better Patient Care, Kyoto,
Japan, April 10-13, 1991.
[Ist99] Information Society Technologies, IST-1999-10025, WIN-FLEX D4.1, Design
and Performance of Modulation and Diversity Algorithms, 1999.
[Itt61] ITT, Electrical Communication, Volume 37 Number 2, pp.87-116, 1961.
[Itu88] International Telecommunication Union (ITU) G.711 64 Kbps PCM standard,
[Itu89] Comité Consultatif International Télégraphique et Téléphonique (CCITT), IX
Plenary Assembly, Melbourne, 14-25 November 1988, Blue Book, ITU, Geneva, 1989.
[Itu60] Report of Meeting of CCITT Working Party 43 (Data Transmission) Geneva,
21-28 March 1960; Comité Consultatif International Télégraphique et Téléphonique
Document GT 43, Number 20; 30 March 1960.
[Kif01] Kifle, M., and Monty Andro, M., Vanderaar, M. J., An OFDM System Using
Polyphase Filter and DFT Architecture for Very High Data Rate Applications,
NASA/TM—2001-210813, National Aeronautics and Space Administration Glenn Research
Center, Prepared for the 19th International Communications Satellite Systems
Conference and Exhibit cosponsored by the AIAA, CNES, ESA, and SUPAERO, Toulouse,
France, April 17–20, 2001.
[Lei72] Leivo, H., Lallo, P., Automatization of Army Communications (In Finnish:
Armeijakunnan yhteyksien automatisointi), Viestimies, September 3, pp. 138-139, 1972.
[Mah01] Maheu, M.M., et. al. E-Health, Telehealth, and Telemedicine, Jossey-Bass A
Wiley Company, San Francisco, 2001.
[Mar62] Margenau, H., The Mathematics of Physics and Chemistry, D. Van Nostrand
Company, INC. Princeton, NJ, USA, March 1962.
[Mar03] De Marchis, G., Tutorial on Technologies, TelCon srl, ITU-T workshop Outside
plant for the Access Network, Hanoi 24 November 2003.
[Mas97] Masys, D. R., Baker, D. B., Patient-Centered Access to Secure Systems Online
(PCASSO): A Secure Approach to Clinical Data Access Via the World Wide Web, University
of California, San Diego (UCSD) and Science Applications International Corporation
(SAIC) La Jolla, California, 1997.
[Mas98] Masys, D. R., Baker, D. B., Protecting Clinical Data on Web Client Computers:
the PCASSO Approach, University of California, San Diego (UCSD) and Science
Applications International Corporation (SAIC) La Jolla, California, 1998.
[Mas02] Masys, D. R. et. al., Giving Patients Access to Their Medical Records via the
Internet: The PCASSO Experience, Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association,
Volume 9, Number 2 Mar / Apr 2002.
[Mdd90] Scientific Advisory Board for Defence, Digital Telecommunications in Mobile
Networks, Interfaces to Fixed Networks, (In Finnish: Maanpuolustuksen tieteellinen
neuvottelukunta, Tiivistelmä 255, Digitaalinen viestiliikenne liikkuvissa verkoissa,
rajapinnat kiinteisiin televerkkoihin), Final Report 255, Research plan 28/Mdd/90
MATINE. Report series B 1992/1, pp 1-16, Helsinki, www.defmin.fi, 1992.
[Mil03] Military Communications Conference, Milcom 2003 Plenary Session, IEEE
and AFCEA, USA, MA, Boston,15.10.2003.
[Mis98] Missud, P., Monod, S., HTZ Warfare 9.x: Communications Electronic Warfare,
I Paris, Advanced Topographic Development & Images, 1998.
[Mit82] Mitrani, I., Simulation techniques for discrete event simulation, ISBN 0521
238854, Cambridge University Press, 1982.
[Mos02] Moskowitz, I. S., Chang, L. W., Newman, R. E., Capacity is the Wrong Paradigm,
US Government work, Research supported by the Office of Naval Research,
[Noo99] Noordergraaf, A., KeithWatson, K., Solaris™ Operating Environment Network
Settings for Security, - Global Enterprise Security Service Sun BluePrints™
OnLine – December 1999.
[Par00] Parviala, A., Jaarli Jauhiainen initiator of telephone industry (In Finnish: Jaarli
Jauhiainen puhelinalan näkijä ja tekijä), Karisto Oy, Hämeenlinna 2000.
[Pro92] Proakis, J., Manolakis, D., Digital Signal Processing Principles, Algorithms,
and Applications, Macmillan Publishing Company, New York, 1992.
[Rad80] Radio Shack, Personal Software Visicalc TRS-80 Model I, Micro Computer
System, Catalog Number 26-1566, First Edition, TRDDOS Operating System: 1979
Tandy Corporation, VisiCalc Program: 1979, 1980 Software Arts, Inc., VisiCalc Program
Manual: Personal Softare Inc., 1980.
[Ram02] Ramírez-Mireles, F., et. al., The Benefits of Discrete Multi-Tone (DMT)
Modulation for VDSL Systems, Ikanos Communications, email@example.com, Version
1.4, October 11, 2002.
[Rat05] Ratib, O., Health on the Net (HON): From PACS to the World Wide Web,
http://www.hon.ch/Library/papers/ratib.html 16.01.2005 13:14, 2005.
[Rob99] Robertson P., Kaiser, S., The effects of Doppler spreads on OFDM(A) mobile
radio systems,” in Proc. IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference, vol. 1, pp. 329–333,
[Rob04] Robertson, D., Alec Reeves - The radical who shaped the future, The IEE History
of Technology Professional Network Lecture, Thursday, 28 October 2004 at The
IEE, Savoy Place, London, 2004.
[Rum86] Rummler, W.D., Coutts, R.P., Linger, M., Multipath fading channel models
for microwave digital radio, IEEE Communications Magazine, November 1986, pp.30-
[Sen95] Sengupta, S., Computer Network in Health Care, The Biomedical Enginnering
Handbook, IEEE Press, ISBN 0-8493-8346-3, pp. 2642-2649, 1995.
[Sha48] Shannon, C. E., A Mathematical Theory of Communication, Reprinted with
corrections from The Bell System Technical Journal, Vol. 27, pp. 379–423, 623–656,
July and October, 1948.
[Sha79] Shanmugam, K.S, Digital and Analog Communication Systems, John Wiley &
Sons, New York, 1979.
[Ska01] Sklar, B., Digital Communications Fundamentals and Applications, Prentice
Hall, Inc, New Jersey, 2001.
[SNg03] Ng, S. X., Yee, M. S., Hanzo, L., Radial Basis Function Aided Turbo Equalisation
of Tcm, Ttcm, Bicm and Bicm-Id Assisted Wireless Transceivers, School of ECS,
Univ. of Southampton,
Email:firstname.lastname@example.org, http://www-mobile.ecs.soton.ac.uk, 2003.
[Sta99] Starr T., Cioffi J. M., Silverman and P. J., Understanding Digital Subscriber
Line Technology, Prentice-Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ, 1999.
[Ste91] Steward, B. K., et. al., Performance characteristics of an ultrafast network for
PACS, Proc. SPIE v. 1446, Medical Imaging V, 1991.
[Tes92] Tesoft Inc., Tesla Reference Manual, 1992.
[Ung82] Ungerboeck, G., Channel coding with multilevel/phase signals, IEEE Trans.
Inform. Theory, vol. IT-28, pp. 55–67, Jan. 1982.
[Var03] Distributed Communication Sy tem in Biomedical Applications, Péter Várady,
Dept. of Control Engineering and Information Technology, Technical University of
Budapest, Hungary 1111 Budapest, Mûegyetem rkp. 9, Hungary E-mail:
[Vit67] Viterbi, A. J., Error bounds for convolutional codes and an asymptotically optimum
decoding algorithm, IEEE Trans. Information Theory, vol. IT-13, pp. 260-269,
[Web94] Webster’s New Encyclopedic Dictionary, Köneman, Cologne, Germany,
Third Edition, 1994.
[Wei71] S. B. Weinstein and P. M. Ebert, Data transmission by frequency division multiplexing
using the discrete Fourier transform, IEEE Trans.Commun. Technol., vol.
COM-19, pp. 628–634, Oct. 1971.